Overdue Captain America: Civil War Review
May. 13th, 2016 08:08 am I'm here in a Starbucks in Chicago, waiting for the SFWA Nebula Conference to wake up, so I thought I'd finally write down a few thoughts about Captain America: Civil War.
Generally, I liked it. There are a few things I think I can say about the movie 'above the cut.' as it were. Without spoiling, I want to talk about one of the fundamental differences between the movie and the comic book arc. In the comic book, like the movie, there is an event that triggers a public outcry about the unchecked destruction that superheroes cause when they come blundering into situations, do their best, but sometimes civilian lives are lost. In the comic book arc, the difference is that the destruction is caused, quite accidentally, by random "new" superheroes. That's to say, "powered" people who have no affiliation with a superhero group like the X-Men or the Avengers. As a result, part of what the public demands is a "superhero registration act" which not only requires any people with powers to offer themselves to the government, but ALSO requires long-standing superheroes to expose their secret identities as part of registration.
I think you can already see why, in the comic book version, someone from World War II might stop and say, "Uh... wait a minute... You gonna ask us all to wear stars next?" (He had other really amazing observations which really resonated with everything that was happening during the time Civil War was written, which was during the Patriot Act, which DIRECTLY commented on things happening in the US.)
In the movie (and this isn't much of a spoiler, because, in many ways the movie is actually about Bucky's past), the accords only require the superheroes to subject themselves to oversight. Now, the question is a lot more nebulous: who is in charge, what decisions do they get to make... ?
But, what's missing in the movie is Captain America being far more articulate and CLEAR about why he, specifically, finds this situation squicky. The thing that drove me absolutely buggy (later... because during the movie my only thoughts were: bam! crash! zap!) was that it was certainly all set up in the previous Captain America movies. All we would have needed is, during the scene where the gathered Avengers are looking over the accord (I do love that it's clear Captain America read EVERY PAGE) to have Cap say, "Guys, really? We're going to put our trust in a governing body... WHEN HYDRA WAS SECRETLY IN CONTROL OF S.H.I.E.L.D. FOR THE PAST FIFTY YEARS??"
MCU Captain America has a LEGIT reason not to want to sign something that gives away his decision making power to an organization he knows nothing about.
But, so. like, *I* thought of that, but it was _never_ said out loud by ANYONE in the movie.
Which to me, made Captain America seem like a war-mongering vigilante.... which is... super not Captain America.
That's not to say there weren't things I loved. Again, no spoilers, but I thought Black Panther moved EXACTLY RIGHT. I was having flashbacks to comic books I barely remember reading every time he did a jump or a four-point landing or a swipe with his vibranium claws.
Also, I loved Peter Parker/Spider-Man
Okay, a couple things I can't say without a spoiler block...
( Read more... )So, those of you who saw it, what are your thoughts?
Generally, I liked it. There are a few things I think I can say about the movie 'above the cut.' as it were. Without spoiling, I want to talk about one of the fundamental differences between the movie and the comic book arc. In the comic book, like the movie, there is an event that triggers a public outcry about the unchecked destruction that superheroes cause when they come blundering into situations, do their best, but sometimes civilian lives are lost. In the comic book arc, the difference is that the destruction is caused, quite accidentally, by random "new" superheroes. That's to say, "powered" people who have no affiliation with a superhero group like the X-Men or the Avengers. As a result, part of what the public demands is a "superhero registration act" which not only requires any people with powers to offer themselves to the government, but ALSO requires long-standing superheroes to expose their secret identities as part of registration.
I think you can already see why, in the comic book version, someone from World War II might stop and say, "Uh... wait a minute... You gonna ask us all to wear stars next?" (He had other really amazing observations which really resonated with everything that was happening during the time Civil War was written, which was during the Patriot Act, which DIRECTLY commented on things happening in the US.)
In the movie (and this isn't much of a spoiler, because, in many ways the movie is actually about Bucky's past), the accords only require the superheroes to subject themselves to oversight. Now, the question is a lot more nebulous: who is in charge, what decisions do they get to make... ?
But, what's missing in the movie is Captain America being far more articulate and CLEAR about why he, specifically, finds this situation squicky. The thing that drove me absolutely buggy (later... because during the movie my only thoughts were: bam! crash! zap!) was that it was certainly all set up in the previous Captain America movies. All we would have needed is, during the scene where the gathered Avengers are looking over the accord (I do love that it's clear Captain America read EVERY PAGE) to have Cap say, "Guys, really? We're going to put our trust in a governing body... WHEN HYDRA WAS SECRETLY IN CONTROL OF S.H.I.E.L.D. FOR THE PAST FIFTY YEARS??"
MCU Captain America has a LEGIT reason not to want to sign something that gives away his decision making power to an organization he knows nothing about.
But, so. like, *I* thought of that, but it was _never_ said out loud by ANYONE in the movie.
Which to me, made Captain America seem like a war-mongering vigilante.... which is... super not Captain America.
That's not to say there weren't things I loved. Again, no spoilers, but I thought Black Panther moved EXACTLY RIGHT. I was having flashbacks to comic books I barely remember reading every time he did a jump or a four-point landing or a swipe with his vibranium claws.
Also, I loved Peter Parker/Spider-Man
Okay, a couple things I can't say without a spoiler block...
( Read more... )So, those of you who saw it, what are your thoughts?